Skip to content

Why Updating WordPress Matters (And Why You Shouldn’t Just Click Update All)

One of the most common questions I hear from business owners is simple: “If my WordPress website is working fine, why do I need to keep updating it?”

It’s a fair question. When a website looks good and customers can use it, updates can feel like an unnecessary expense or an invitation for something to break. But after years of building and maintaining WordPress websites at Calico Design, I’ve seen the other side: websites that go too long without updates often become harder, riskier, and more expensive to maintain.

WordPress maintenance isn’t about chasing the latest version number. It’s about keeping your website secure, compatible, reliable, and ready to support your business.

Why WordPress Websites Need Regular Updates

A WordPress website is made of several moving parts: WordPress itself, your theme, plugins, hosting software, and often integrations with outside services. These parts evolve independently. An update to one can improve compatibility with another—or expose a problem that needs attention.

1. Security vulnerabilities get fixed

Security is one of the biggest reasons to stay current. When developers discover a vulnerability, they may release a patch that closes it. Leaving an outdated plugin or theme installed can keep that known weakness available to attackers.

That doesn’t mean every outdated plugin will be hacked, or that updating makes a website invulnerable. It means timely, well-managed updates reduce avoidable exposure. For a business website collecting inquiries, processing transactions, or handling customer accounts, that matters.

2. Plugins and themes need to stay compatible

WordPress is an ecosystem. Your page builder, forms, custom fields, SEO tools, and booking integrations all have to work together. Developers release updates to support new WordPress and PHP versions, adjust to changing APIs, and fix conflicts.

Skip updates for long enough and a seemingly simple change can become a complicated project. A plugin may no longer support the site’s PHP version. A theme may rely on deprecated code. A form integration may stop behaving as expected.

3. Updates fix bugs and improve performance

Not every update is about security. Some address bugs, improve accessibility, reduce resource usage, or make a feature work more reliably. A site that loads today may still have a problem hiding in a mobile menu, checkout step, or contact form.

Updates can help, but they aren’t a substitute for good hosting, optimized media, or clean development. Performance depends on the whole website—not just its software versions.

Why I Don’t Recommend Blindly Updating Everything

Here’s where I disagree with the idea that WordPress maintenance is just clicking an “Update All” button once a month.

Updates sometimes cause problems. A plugin can introduce a bug. A theme update can change styling. A PHP upgrade can reveal outdated custom code. Even a routine update can expose a conflict that was already waiting beneath the surface.

That’s why the goal isn’t to update recklessly; it’s to update responsibly. The more complex the website, the more important the process becomes.

Our Approach to WordPress Updates at Calico Design

When we’re maintaining a client website, I want to know not only that an update was installed, but that the site still does what the business needs it to do afterward.

  1. Review what’s changing. Check the updates available, their importance, and any known compatibility considerations. Security fixes deserve prompt attention.
  2. Confirm a usable backup. Before significant changes, make sure there’s a current backup of the website’s files and database, with a practical way to restore it.
  3. Use staging when appropriate. For complex websites, major version changes, or important integrations, test changes on a staging environment before applying them to the live site.
  4. Apply updates in a controlled way. Avoid piling major software changes on top of one another without checking the results.
  5. Test the website. Check the homepage, important landing pages, navigation, mobile layouts, forms, and any critical business functions.
  6. Watch for problems afterward. Error logs, uptime monitoring, and follow-up checks can reveal issues that aren’t obvious immediately.

A successful update notification is not the same thing as a successful maintenance session.

What Should You Test After Updating WordPress?

Every website is different. For a simple brochure website, the key checks may be navigation, responsive layouts, and contact forms. For a restaurant website, I’d pay particular attention to menus, reservations, ordering links, and event pages. For an online store, the cart and checkout process are critical.

At a minimum, I recommend checking:

  • Homepage and high-traffic pages on desktop and mobile
  • Navigation, buttons, and important calls to action
  • Contact forms and confirmation emails
  • Custom post types, filters, search, and dynamic content
  • Reservations, checkout, memberships, or other transactions
  • Site speed, major layout changes, and PHP or JavaScript errors

Some problems only appear when a real visitor takes a specific action. That’s why testing the actual customer journey is more valuable than simply opening the homepage.

Should You Enable Automatic WordPress Updates?

Automatic updates can be useful, especially for low-risk changes and security patches. But I wouldn’t treat every website or plugin the same way.

For a straightforward site with reliable backups and monitoring, carefully selected automatic updates may make sense. For a complex site with custom functionality, critical forms, eCommerce, or multiple integrations, I’d be more selective. Automatic updates without monitoring can leave a broken feature unnoticed.

My preference is a managed process that balances speed and verification. Critical security updates shouldn’t sit indefinitely, but neither should a complicated business website be treated like a disposable test environment.

Don’t Forget PHP, Hosting, and Abandoned Plugins

Updating WordPress core and plugins is only part of maintenance. The hosting environment matters too.

PHP versions eventually reach the end of security support. An outdated server environment can create risks even when WordPress itself is current. On the other hand, changing PHP without checking theme and plugin compatibility can break older code.

I also look for plugins that appear abandoned, are no longer needed, or duplicate functionality. A plugin with no available updates isn’t necessarily healthy; sometimes it means nobody is maintaining it. Removing unused software and replacing unsupported tools can be just as important as installing updates.

How Often Should You Update Your WordPress Website?

There’s no universal schedule for every website, but I recommend regular review rather than waiting for something to fail. Security-related updates may require prompt action, while larger feature upgrades can be planned and tested.

The right frequency depends on the website’s complexity, traffic, and business impact. A site accepting orders or reservations has different risks from a simple informational website. The important thing is having someone accountable for reviewing updates, applying them, and confirming the site still works.

What Happens When You Ignore WordPress Maintenance?

Often, nothing dramatic happens right away. That’s what makes neglect tempting.

But over time, outdated components accumulate. Eventually you may face a plugin that can’t be upgraded without replacing another, a PHP version your hosting provider no longer supports, a broken integration, or a security incident that could have been avoided.

At that point, the work may be closer to a repair or rebuild than routine maintenance. Staying current in manageable steps is generally easier than trying to catch up on years of changes at once.

WordPress Maintenance Is More Than Clicking Update

At Calico Design, we’ve built and maintained WordPress websites across a wide range of industries. The biggest lesson I’ve learned is that a website needs ongoing attention after launch.

Good maintenance includes software updates, backups, security review, monitoring, and testing the features customers actually use. It protects the investment you’ve already made in your website and helps keep it working as your business evolves.

A website that’s running today isn’t necessarily a website that’s being maintained. That’s the difference worth paying attention to.

Calico Design is a premier web design and marketing agency in the Chicago and Tampa / St. Pete Florida areas. 

Explore Blog

A WordPress website can look perfect on Monday and be in trouble by Tuesday. A plugin update conflicts with the theme. A server fails. Someone accidentally deletes an important page. Or a website is compromised and needs to be restored quickly. After...
Meet Calico Canonical Redirects, a free WordPress plugin for consolidating HTTP, HTTPS, www, and non-www URLs with a safer preview-to-301 workflow.
AI is changing how people discover businesses, products, services, and information online. But I don’t believe that means we need to throw out everything we know about SEO and replace it with a new collection of acronyms. In many ways, AI search...
Building a restaurant website in Elementor is usually pretty straightforward — until you get to the menu. A simple menu with an item name, description, and price isn’t difficult. But real restaurant menus aren’t always that simple. You start dealing with different...
*Note – this video is a bit old, plugins might look a little different, but the information is the same.   A WordPress contact form can appear to work perfectly while the most important part is quietly failing: the notification email never reaches...
Video can make a website look incredible, but it can also become one of the largest files a visitor has to download. This becomes especially important when you’re using autoplaying hero videos, background videos, animated graphics, event footage, or other video-heavy website...